{"schema":"plot.claim/v1","address":{"kind":"claim","id":"C41N-G5","version":1,"latest_version":1,"is_latest":true,"release":null,"url":"https://www.plot.eco/c/C41N-G5","formats":{"html":"https://www.plot.eco/c/C41N-G5","json":"https://www.plot.eco/c/C41N-G5.json","md":"https://www.plot.eco/c/C41N-G5.md","embed":"https://www.plot.eco/c/C41N-G5/embed"}},"record_type":"observation","statement":"The writer reports seeing grebes year after year in rough water off Williamstown.","about":{"id":"ZKM8-1W","name":"Williamstown","kind":"place","url":"https://www.plot.eco/p/williamstown","place":"https://www.plot.eco/p/williamstown"},"object":null,"measure":"Historical passage","value":{"text":"Although particularly to be seen in inland and coastal lagoons, they often venture from river mouths into turbulent waters, where I have noticed them year after year off Williamstown.","number":null,"lower":null,"upper":null,"comparator":"=","unit":null},"caveats":{"kind":"source_reported","kind_label":"Reported by source","origin":"community_reported","origin_label":"Reported by community","period":{"text":"1894","start":"1894-01-01","end":"1894-12-31"},"verification":{"level":"reviewed","label":"Reviewed","step":3,"of":4,"meaning":"PLOT checked the claim against its source. This is not independent verification.","basis":"person","basis_note":"Checked by a person."},"open_questions":{"count":0,"note":"Open questions and challenges are counted publicly; their text is published when they are resolved."}},"temporal_status":"historic","method":"accounts-core@0.1.0: screen_passage@1, extract_passage@1 (claude-opus-5-5 (Claude Code session)); locator victoriannatural11fiel, leaf 54, printed page 44","uncertainty":null,"limitations":"A writer's account: context and a reason to look again, never a measurement. The writer's words for the place are kept; silence elsewhere is not absence.","explanation":null,"source":{"title":"The Victorian naturalist, v.11, 1894-1895","publisher":"Field Naturalists' Club of Victoria","url":"https://archive.org/details/victoriannatural11fiel","locator":"victoriannatural11fiel, leaf 54, printed page 44","page":44,"plot_url":"https://www.plot.eco/s/FYKB-EH?snippet=cde9bf34-88c4-4e94-b2ba-000068649311"},"framework_targets":[],"editions":["october-26th-release"],"history":[{"version":1,"change_reason":null,"current":true}],"resolved_questions":[],"sourcing":{"found":"by_protocol","summary":"Found under sourcing protocol accounts-core@0.1.0, for the question \"Species written about here\", in historical_archives. Screened in on an AI proposal (Claude Opus 5.5 (AI), for review). Extracted with claude-opus-5-5 (Claude Code session), prompt extract_passage@1; a person reviewed it before publication.","protocol":{"id":"accounts-core","version":"0.1.0"},"note":"accounts-core run williamstown-2026-10-23: Internet Archive texts (Victorian Naturalist v.1-37, Letters from Victorian Pioneers) and ALA specimen facets. Trove and BHL blocked: they need API keys.","question":{"key":"Q31.hist_species_presence","title":"Species written about here"},"channel":{"id":"historical_archives","label":"historical_archives"},"query":{"text":"Williamstown | Williams Town | Williams-town | Point Gellibrand | Gellibrand's Point | Gellibrand Point | Jawbone | Greenwich Bay in archive.org/victoriannatural11fiel","engine":"archive.org OCR text, local full-text match"},"screening":{"decision":"include","reason_code":"meets_criteria","rationale":"Grebes seen year after year off Williamstown.","decided_by":"ai_proposed","label":"Claude Opus 5.5 (AI), for review","prompt_ref":"screen_passage@1","model_ref":"claude-opus-5-5 (Claude Code session)"},"extraction":{"prompt_ref":"extract_passage@1","model_ref":"claude-opus-5-5 (Claude Code session)"}},"jobs":null,"cite_as":"PLOT record c/C41N-G5 v1, Field Naturalists' Club of Victoria (1894), reported by source"}